Clive,
I basically agree with you.
But I just wonder how many people really need the menu options and
keyboard shortcuts to copy and paste unformatted test... because for me
that is absolutely essential.
Why?
Because I use it hundreds of times every day. Because I work with
documents in which I am constantly copying and pasting text from/to
many different sources, including web pages, PDF files, emails, etc.
On the other hand the proposed keyboard shortcuts are not because they
are easy or difficult; it is just because they are standard in other
applications (as an example, you can check out Eudora mail):
Shift Command C to copy unformatted text.
Shift Command V to paste unformatted text.
Regards,
---
On 2005-03-21 23:34:08 +0100, Clive Huggan
<
[email protected]> said:
Hello Tony,
I've been following your post with some interest.
I don't hold a torch for Microsoft, but from the things I observe here and
elsewhere, there are features that squillions of people hold dear and want
to see in Word "out of the box". Some of these people are even as
passionate as you about their wishes! (Don't take that at all negatively
--
there isn't enough passion around!)
I get the impression that Microsoft carefully analyses the needs of the
majority of users (who use Word as a typewriter; Word comes with their job;
and they want to know the minimum to produce work required by their boss
without having to delve into this and that). Then, for reasons I can only
guess at, including historic motivations to throttle every competing
product
on the market (a motivation of the free enterprise system that has given us
unprecedented prosperity, despite its well-known downsides), they have
added
additional functionality.
The key to some of this extra functionality is that if a user is prepared
to
take time to learn to apply configurations he/she prefers, some wonderful
results can ensue. I find that in some of my work the improvement in
efficiency, hence income, is 20%. That's why I appreciate that Word can be
configured so extensively.
However, if Microsoft responded to everybody's requests for "extras" in the
out-of-the-box configuration, the product would be more daunting than at
present. And I think that would be a major problem.
In my experience of "ordinary" (but intelligent) users in my [non-IT]
consulting work, they never have a need to paste unformatted text. Even if
they did, most would not want default keyboard shortcuts (PC users of Word,
for example, don't use keyboard shortcuts nearly as much as Mac users do).
I use this facility frequently in my work, but I would not want the
keyboard
shortcuts you propose -- they aren't as easy on the fingers as others, and
I
can't see the point of having a "copy unformatted text", since Command-c is
all that's required.
So the moral is (only IMHO) that once you learn how to configure Word, you
can apply what you want, not what an analysis of innumerable out-of-the-box
users has produced. It's empowerment, in its own small way.
BTW, you don't have to re-do your configurations when you upgrade or
re-install Word (with a couple of very minor exceptions).
<end rant>
<Anyone still there? No? Well, it felt good while I was doing it. Now I
must go back to earning a living.>
As to John's "power" that you attribute, I'll leave that to him... ;-)
Cheers,
Clive Huggan Canberra, Australia
(My time zone is at least 5 hours different from the US and Europe, so my
follow-on responses to those regions can be delayed)
============================================================
On 22/3/05 12:34 AM, in article 2005032114340850073%nospam@nospamcom,
"Tony"
John,
Thanks. I did indeed...
But I just wanted to suggest a way to have it standard from the
manufacturer now and always. If you do it yourself customizing Word,
that is OK for the moment, but when you re-install on the same or other
Mac, or when new versions come out, you must re-do things. That is the
way I see things.
I do not know about other people, but I use the special paste as simple
text hundreds of times every day! So a standard menu and command for it
would be nice:
Shift Comman C to copy unformatted text.
Shift Comman V to paste unformatted text.
And I tell you that because I know you have "power" on Microsoft
development policies, so if I could "convince" you I am quite sure that
it would be implemented...
Regards,
---
On 2005-03-21 10:43:49 +0100, "John McGhie [MVP - Word and Word
Macintosh]" <
[email protected]> said:
They have -- it's up to you to read the Help
You can put anything you like on the menus, or keyboard commands.
However, if you had thought a minute about what I wrote in my response,
you
may have understood that it does both.
That is the Users helping other Users way.
On 20/3/05 04:00, in article 2005031918001243658%nospam@nospamcom, "Tony"
John,
Thanks.
It would be good if Microsoft could implement it also as keyboard
commands and as menu options.
That is the Mac way.
---
On 2005-03-19 12:56:23 +0100, "John McGhie [MVP - Word and Word
Macintosh]" <
[email protected]> said:
Hi Tony:
That's exactly what I use (I normally use the INSERT key to paste as
Formatted, and Command + V to paste as unformatted).
Copy Robert's macro, put it in your Normal template, and name it
EditPaste.
Most Word "commands" are actually macros. If you have a macro of the
same
name, its functionality replaces the command.
I actually use two macros:
Sub EditPaste()
On Error GoTo notAvailable
Selection.PasteSpecial Link:=False, DataType:=20
End
notAvailable:
Selection.Paste
End Sub
Sub EditPasteFormatted()
Selection.Paste
End Sub
The first macro uses a very crude "On Error" method of trapping the
condition where "plain text" is not one of the formats available on the
clipboard. It's crude, but it works: and saves you having to
successively
try each option to find out what the hell *is* on the clipboard.
VBA does not have a way to examine the clipboard to see what actually
is
there. There is usually a selection of formats (can be five or six,
depending on the application you copied from). This can be a little
character building, because the "data" is not actually ON the clipboard
of
the source application is still open. There's just a pointer to it,
and
the
source application then produces the data to the clipboard in the
format
you
request when you ask for it.
Cheers
On 15/3/05 05:16, in article 2005031419163416807%nospam@nospamcom,
"Tony"
Hi,
The best would be a keyboard shortcut:
Shift Comman C to copy unformatted text.
Shift Comman V to paste unformatted text.
As appliations like Eudora 6 do.
---
On 2005-03-14 16:15:24 +0100, (e-mail address removed) (matt neuburg) said:
On 11/3/05 2:02 PM, in article
1gt9697.p4tjra17sxa5kN%
[email protected],
When I paste special it is virtually always unformatted text. I
have
tried through customization (but it is not an option there) and
macros
(they don't work, they just paste with all the formatting as well)
to
make a single key stroke, e.g., shift-command v, to paste text
only?
Entourage actually allows you to, so it is odd that Word doesn't.
BTW, the macro as I recorded it is:
Sub Pastetext()
'
' Pastetext Macro
' Macro recorded 10/3/05 by Robert M. Lewis
'
Selection.PasteSpecial Link:=False, DataType:=wdPasteText,
Placement:= _ wdInLine, DisplayAsIcon:=False
End Sub
That can be shortened, but yes, that's exactly how I do it. Works
fine.
What's the problem you're having? m.
It doesn't paste unformatted text, the text is formatted.
What if you choose Paste Special > Unformatted? Does that give a
different result from what this macro gives, when copying the same
material from the same source? m.