Durations: Months, Emonths, Edays equal??

M

mramay

I'm trying to put a 30 month task into a Project 2007 file.

Standard (base) calendar (the default calendar)
Automatically updated (e.g., latest) version of Proj. 2007
30 months = 913.125 days (365.25 day/yr), = 4/1/11
9/30/08 start date

Project Durations:
"30 mons" results in 1/7/11
"30 emons" results in 3/19/11
"913 edays" results in 4/1/11

Why the differences? I expected that 30 emons would give me the 4/1/11
date, but it was off by several weeks?

Am I doing something wrong or is Proj 2007 SNAFU on this??

Thanks,
Mike R.
 
R

Rod Gill

Months in Project are not worth using! They default to 20 working days and
are therefore a poor approximation of a month. Stick with weeks.

--

Rod Gill
Microsoft MVP for Project

Author of the only book on Project VBA, see:
http://www.projectvbabook.com
 
B

B Sai Prasad [PMP]

Hi mramay -

I agree with Rod Gill. By default, MS Project assumes the 1 month = 20
working days.

Though not worth, if you like to alter this then choose Tools, Options,
Calendar and change Days per month field.

If this helps, please consider rating my suggestion.
 
S

Steve House

"30 Months" duration equals the calendar date range wherein 600 (30 * 20
work days in an average month) days * 8 hours per day * 60 minutes per hour,
minutes worth of working time will have gone past according to the Project
working time calendar, any non-working time not being counted. A calendar
timespan of 3 consecutive weeks running Sun through Sat, 21 days, in which 2
out of every 7 days are non-working (ie, a normal workweek of Mon thru Fri
with Sat Sun off) will be 15 days duration. A timespan from the first of
the month through the last day of the month may be 18, 19, 20, 21, or 22
days duration depending on the day of the week the first falls, which exact
month of the year you're looking at, and in the case of February whether
it's a leap year or not. But a calendar month absolutely will never be 28,
29, 30 or 31 days of duration unless your resources are slaves who never get
any time off whatsoever.

"30 emonths" is the calendar date range during which 900 consecutive 24-hour
days (30 months * 30 average edays per month) have elapsed without any
distinction made between working and non-working days.

"913 edays" is the calendar date range during which 913 consecutive 24-hour
days will have elapsed, no distinction being made between working and
non-working days.

Project always figures duration in minutes, non-working minutes not
counting. In a very real sense there can be no such thing as a 30 calendar
month task per se where the task is defined by its time-frame. Think about
it - tasks are never driven forward by the mere passage of time. Instead
they are driven by resources doing physical activity and the only time
activity happens is when the resource is present and working. If the task
requires X amount of labour to achieve its deliverable, it will span
whatever date range wherein the resource does that amount of activity. That
means the actual date range of that task will span whatever time frame where
the resource will do 30 months worth of whatever is defined as full time
equivalent work in your organization - the actual date range will vary
wildly depending on the resource's time commitment.

A hint - if possible try to avoid tasks that long. A good rule of thumb is
the 8/80 rule which says tasks with a work effort of less than 8 hours are
usually the result of excessive micromanagment while tasks that require more
than 80 hours are too big to manage effectively.

Hope this helps
--
Steve House [Project MVP]
MS Project Trainer & Consultant
Visit http://project.mvps.org/faqs.htm for the FAQs
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top