What the publisher told you may have had to do with the manuscript format
the publishing house wanted to receive, based on how their software would
deal with the file. There are many such limitations (often a tremendous
hardship for Word users), such as wanting all the footnotes or endnotes in a
separate file. I have known publishers to require two hyphens to represent
an en dash and three for an em dash; again, that was for the convenience of
their conversion software.
In traditional typesetting, an ellipsis is set as individual periods with
spaces (possibly thin ones) between. In Word you can reproduce this by using
a space before and after the periods and nonbreaking spaces between them
(this is actually superior to an ellipsis in some ways because the ellipsis
character is nonbreaking, which is often inconvenient). Periods with no
spaces between are too close together; periods with ordinary spaces may look
too spacey.
And the instructions may well have been intended for monospaced fonts, where
periods with no spaces would be spaced appropriately, and if the
instructions were intended for a typewriter, then of course there is no en
dash (so a hyphen must be used), and two hyphens are used to represent an em
dash. FWIW, when I was a typist (before I moved to computers), I always used
the half-backspace key to back up and overstrike the two hyphens to make
them continuous--just one of many refinements (such as changing typeballs
for italics and special characters) that gave me a competitive edge in a
typewriter world. <g>
--
Suzanne S. Barnhill
Microsoft MVP (Word)
Words into Type
Fairhope, Alabama USA
http://word.mvps.org
That's right, and where they are used in the text depends on the house
style
of the publisher, or the whims of the author in unpublished documents.
Wow, I truly did not know there was a difference between an en dash
and a hyphen. I suppose this leads me to my next quibble (because--at
least to my eye--there is no discernible difference between the two).
If I type an ellipses, Autotext automatically re-spaces it to add
additional space between the three Periods.
Once an editor (1996) told me this was "wrong"; ellipses should be
foreshortened, for lack of a better term, he said. So I'd backspace or
whatever operation is necessary to undo the extra Autotext spacing.
Along came Adobe Reader's read-it-aloud feature. When "Anna" reads
aloud ellipses I have removed the Autotext extra spacing from (to
create three periods in a row), "Anna" actually reads "Sally and Dick
and Jane walked up the hill Dot Dot Dot" (as in "Sally and Dick and
Jane walked up the hill...") But when I use Autotext ellipses ("Sally
and Dick and Jane walked up the hill . . ."), "Anna" doesn't read the
Dot Dot Dot.
Again, when the editor (major NYC publishing house) told me this, I
assumed it was gospel. And in regard to the en dash/hyphen question, I
was told there was no difference. Anyway, thanks to both of you folks.