Hi Thomas -
It's certainly understandable that some might not be happy with the change,
but there isn't much we in the newsgroup can do about it - we're users of
the product just like you, not MS employees
if you want to register your
dissatisfaction where it will count, use Help> Send Feedback form Excel's
menu & fully support your preference.
When you do, though, it would be best if you have your facts straight
Print Preview has never supported *any* formatting changes to the sheets for
the very reasons Bob G. expressed - Print Preview is generated by the
printer driver & the OS and was simply hosted by the program. To that end,
Apple's OS X guidelines have been moving toward channeling developers toward
the Preview application interface provided by the OS.
What you are recalling is Page Break Preview - a totally separate & distinct
view which allowed formatting changes plus other sheet editing & page break
adjustment but didn't allow margin changes or other Setup options without
launching the Page Setup dialog.
Page Break Preview was replaced in 2008 by Page Layout View, which is more
or less a hybrid of the two but doesn't provide all the functionality of
either. Margins can be adjusted via the Ruler and all editing is enabled,
you just can't move the page breaks. [Quite frankly, that "feature" has
caused more grief & aggravation for most people due to its tendency to
impose unwanted scaling as well as induce other anomalies.] Additionally
Page Layout View allows direct access to Headers & Footers as well as other
Page Setup options (through the Formatting Palette) without having to launch
the Page Setup dialog.
It is unequivocally *different* than what we're used to, but many who have
chosen to work with it find that it's more versatile, more convenient and
overall an improvement over the old UI.
Regards |:>)
Bob Jones
[MVP] Office:Mac
Dear Mr. Bob Greenblatt and Mr. Phillip Jones,
I did not mean to make the print preview function in Excel 2004 for Mac seem
simplistic. I did say you could "make corrections" and "generally
troubleshoot" a workbook as a way of avoiding detailing the many things that
could be tweaked from the Print Preview menu in the old version. But you are
right, Mr. Jones, there is almost no formatting issue that you could not
address in Print Preview 2004. And so it became an extremely valuable
timesaver (and paper saver). As Mr. Jones suggested, now you have to go
through many, many more steps to achieve the same result.
I would suggest, Mr. Greenblatt, that perhaps you never had occasion to use
the old Print Preview function. I am sure that if you were familiar with its
many capabilities you would not as quickly have decided it was removed because
"printing is a function of the OS". To someone knowledgeable, that statement
is misleading at best and I am reasonably sure that you would not mislead
Mactopia users with forethought or foreknowledge.
The Print Preview function 2004 had less to do with printing and more to do
with the ability to quickly and efficiently correct any and all formatting
mistakes. Those mistakes, of course, become more visible in a print preview
mode and the ability to make those adjustments right from Print Preview
constituted a very valuable timesaver.
Quick and efficient functionality would certainly be at the top of most
programmers list of Important Things To Maintain When Upgrading Software, so
for Microsoft to glibly and rigidly proclaim that PRINTING IS A FUNCTION OF
THE OS AND ERGO... NO MORE PRINT PREVIEW is all very nice but does not address
the reality which is that the removal of this particular function surely
qualifies as a Downgrade in a piece of software to which I thought I was
Upgrading.
I hope that MS will put Print Preview back in the next upgrade of Office 2008
for Mac, otherwise I will return mine to my vender and go back Office 2004 for
Mac and be on the lookout for appropriate substitutes in the marketplace.
Mr. Greenblatt, can you comment on any of this or on whether some of these
deletions might be addressed in the next upgrade.
Thanks,
Thomas