Golf scorecard again

K

kevhatch

Is there a formula for this?
Stableford Golf Scores.
To work out a players total points based on their handicap.


Each hole is handicapped (Stroke Index 1-18). The players handicap
indicates the hole upon which he can deduct a stroke,
ie. Players handicap is -4, he deducts a stroke on each of the first four
handicapped holes.
If his handicap is -28, he deducts a stroke on each hole, 1-18 and an
additional stroke on holes handicapped 1 thru 10. (His handicap minus 18).
Players handicaps run from -0 to -28.

Points are scored as follows:
1 over par= 1pt
par= 2pt
1 under par= 3pt
2 under par= 4pt
3 under par= 5pt

I have started one based on a 28 handicap which I think is correct, and
posted it here:

http://www.flypicture.com?display=updone&id=qtr1m6U=

Is there a way it can be worked with variable Stroke Indexes (for different
courses) and handicaps (different players)?
Sounds impossible to me but I'm sure you guys can figure it out.
Thx
 
M

Max

One play ..

Put in D6:
=IF(C6="",0,IF(C$4<$B6-18,C6-2,C6-1))

Put in E6:
=IF(D6=0,0,IF(OR(C$3-D6<-1,C$3-D6>3),0,VLOOKUP(C$3-D6,{-1,1;0,2;1,3;2,4;3,5}
,2)))

Select D6:E6 and copy / paste to G6:H6, J6:K6, M6:N6, P6:Q6, S6:T6, V6:W6,
Y6:Z6, AB6:AC6

Then just select D6:AD6 and fill down as many rows as required (but erase
all the dummy scores in row 6 first)

Sample file with the implemented construct available at:
http://www.savefile.com/files/8674458
File: GolfScoreCard_kevhatch_newusers_1.xls
 
K

kevhatch

Thx Max,
That works great with a 28 handicap. Is there a way it can be made to work
if the h/cap were variable, as they can change for each player from time to
time?

Players handicap of:
1 to 18 allowed 1stroke only on stroke index holes corresponding to their
h/cap.
i.e. player h/cap of 3 allowed one stroke on holes of s/index 1 - 3 etc.

Players handicap of:
19 to 28 allowed 1 stroke on all 18 holes, in addition to 1 extra stroke on
each of the hardest holes corresponding to their h/cap.
i.e. player h/cap of 22 allowed one stroke for each hole plus one extra
stroke on holes of s/index 1 - 4 etc.
Thx again
 
M

Max

.. made to work if the h/cap were variable ..

Thought variable handicaps (besides variable par and stroke indexes) was
already catered for in the suggested formulas, no? (Based, of course, on a
best effort interp of the complexities posed by a non-golfer <g>)

In the sample file provided, in Sheet1, try inputting other handicaps (but
with the same dummy scores for easy comparison) on subsequent rows 7 - 10
(I've pre-loaded the formulas to row10). Also keep the other 2 variables,
par and the stroke indexes unchanged to comparison. Check whether the
formula returns are as expected for a couple of test h/cap cases. Try it and
post back.
--
Rgds
Max
xl 97
---
GMT+8, 1° 22' N 103° 45' E
xdemechanik <at>yahoo<dot>com
----
kevhatch said:
Thx Max,
That works great with a 28 handicap. Is there a way it can be , as they
can change for each player from time to
 
K

kevhatch

ok max, thx. sorry to be a pain.
I have applied and tested the formula and found a few discrepencies.
Uploaded here:

http://www.savefile.com/files/4982248

Table 1 shows:
what the extra shot allowance should be per hole according to players h/cap
and the stroke index of each hole.

Table 2 is showing the formula results. Discrepencies being the blue figures.

Hope all this makes sense.
Thx
Kev
 
B

Biff

Hi!

I tried downloading your file from the link you posted but it didn't work.
Bad link?

I was able to download Max's file.....

Is that how your file is laid out?

UGH! <vbg>

I have a sample file that does what you want. Handles hdcps from 0 to 54 and
includes the modified Stableford scoring system.

Here's a link:

http://s43.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=2VFJ9Q8RVZK4M05IB3HJHRNUJS

That link expires in 7 days or 25 DL's, whichever occurs first.

Biff

kevhatch said:
ok max, thx. sorry to be a pain.
I have applied and tested the formula and found a few discrepencies.
Uploaded here:

http://www.savefile.com/files/4982248

Table 1 shows:
what the extra shot allowance should be per hole according to players
h/cap
and the stroke index of each hole.

Table 2 is showing the formula results. Discrepencies being the blue
figures.

Hope all this makes sense.
Thx
Kev
 
M

Max

Thanks for the clarification, Kev. Ok, thought it more straightforward to
just use your Table 1 (the one with the correct shot allowances) as a
reference source, and revise the earlier formula in D6 to read the figures
direct from Table 1 instead, via an INDEX(...,MATCH(...),MATCH(...)).

Here's the revised sample file: http://www.savefile.com/files/7533806
File: GolfScoreCard_kevhatch_newusers_2.xls

The revised construct hence reads as:

Put in D6:
=IF(C6="",0,C6-INDEX(Chk!$A:$S,MATCH($B6,Chk!$A:$A,0),MATCH(C$4,Chk!$A$5:$S$
5,0)))

(revised formula in D6, Table 1 is in sheet: Chk)

Put in E6:
=IF(D6=0,0,IF(OR(C$3-D6<-1,C$3-D6>3),0,VLOOKUP(C$3-D6,{-1,1;0,2;1,3;2,4;3,5}
,2)))

(no change to formula in E6)

Select D6:E6 and copy / paste to G6:H6, J6:K6, M6:N6, P6:Q6, S6:T6, V6:W6,
Y6:Z6, AB6:AC6

Then just select D6:AD6 and fill down as many rows as required (Erase all
the dummy scores in row 6 first)
 
K

kevhatch

Thx Guys, excellent job. I'm learning..slowly!

Max said:
Thanks for the clarification, Kev. Ok, thought it more straightforward to
just use your Table 1 (the one with the correct shot allowances) as a
reference source, and revise the earlier formula in D6 to read the figures
direct from Table 1 instead, via an INDEX(...,MATCH(...),MATCH(...)).

Here's the revised sample file: http://www.savefile.com/files/7533806
File: GolfScoreCard_kevhatch_newusers_2.xls

The revised construct hence reads as:

Put in D6:
=IF(C6="",0,C6-INDEX(Chk!$A:$S,MATCH($B6,Chk!$A:$A,0),MATCH(C$4,Chk!$A$5:$S$
5,0)))

(revised formula in D6, Table 1 is in sheet: Chk)

Put in E6:
=IF(D6=0,0,IF(OR(C$3-D6<-1,C$3-D6>3),0,VLOOKUP(C$3-D6,{-1,1;0,2;1,3;2,4;3,5}
,2)))

(no change to formula in E6)

Select D6:E6 and copy / paste to G6:H6, J6:K6, M6:N6, P6:Q6, S6:T6, V6:W6,
Y6:Z6, AB6:AC6

Then just select D6:AD6 and fill down as many rows as required (Erase all
the dummy scores in row 6 first)
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

golf scoring 6
Conditional Formula for Golf 1
Golf Score Formula needs tweaking 2
Golf Scores 8
Golf Scores 0
template for scoring a golf league 1
IF Statement for Golf Scores 8
Callaway golf handicap 4

Top