Hi Bob:
Thanx - I love it when a rebuttal actually reinforces the point !
You
make my case as soon as you write:
When you hit "New
Document" it prompted for the file name and location at that point.
The user was *prompted*... the naming & saving didn't happen
*automatically*... And IIRC, if the user failed to respond with the info he
couldn't proceed, creation of the new doc was cancelled & the line-by-line
save never had a chance to take place.
I don't remember: I thought you could simply dismiss the dialog and
continue... This is 1993 we're talking about
I got the impression from the OP's first post that he/she expected to be
able to launch Word, start typing & have everything handled for them from
then on [key words] automatically & "the same way PCs have..." - which is a
dire misconception (I also saw it as an unjust slap at the Mac). That just
doesn't happen on either platform - at least not in any word processing
program I've ever seen over the last 25 years. Even those that have an
AutoSave require that the file be 'manually' saved the first time.
Yes, you're quite correct. On eithe platform, in any Microsoft application,
you will be required to assign a file name in order to get your file BACK.
The really infuriating thing is: it actually works exactly the way the user
wants it to. When Word creates a new file, it opens a disk file in the Temp
folder to store it in.
Sadly, unless the user agrees to assign a file name, Word DELETES the temp
file when it next restarts
If you're quick enough, you can actually get at that file. Just not with
that copy of Word (because if you restart Word, it will delete the file!).
And the file may not actually contain much, unless the Autorecover has had a
chance to kick in (typically ten minutes, unless the user resets it).
However, before people start clamouring for instructions on how to get their
lost files back, lemme give them the bad news... There's anything up to 20
different files for a document. The text is scattered literally at random
amongst the files. And there's no guarantee that it's in any particular
order: Word write shorthand notes to itself. It doesn't assemble them into
a coherent "document" until you officially save. You obviously can't use
Word to open the file (because it will delete the files if you start it...)
And of course, if you have closed the file then reopened a different one,
the temporary file is not there at all
Quite frankly, I'm glad to know that there are still a few remaining
bastions of personal responsibility
If you had a memory like mine, you'd be a lot less enthusiastic about that
"personal responsibility bit"
Cheers
Regards |:>)
Bob Jones
[MVP] Office:Mac
On 8/18/06 12:50 AM, in article (e-mail address removed), "John
Hi Bob:
{Sigh} You young pups...
Borland Sprint saved each line to file as it was typed. When you hit "New
Document" it prompted for the file name and location at that point. There
was no way to lose more than a line of text in Sprint.
No wonder it failed in the marketplace: "My computer crashed and lost my
homework" did not work for either the students or their parents...
So there...