Links to posting in NewsGroup

  • Thread starter Rainald Taesler
  • Start date
R

Rainald Taesler

I would like to place hyperlinks to postings in NewsGroups into ON.
I do not know, however, syntax the URL would need.

How could this be done?

Rainald
P.S. As my newsreader I'm using Outlook Express
 
R

Rainald Taesler

Just bumping it up.
Anybody got any idea?

Rainald


Rainald Taesler shared these words of wisdom:
 
G

Grant Robertson

I would like to place hyperlinks to postings in NewsGroups into
Of course the easiest way is to use google groups. Find the message then
copy the URL out of the address bar of your web browser. I am pretty sure
that it will always take you right back to that exact message. It might
work the same way for the web based reader for the Microsoft newsgroups.
However, this always requires you to be connected to the internet to see
the message.

I have seen hyperlinks to newsgroup messages in other newsgroup messages.
I think they start with "I think they then have the name of the
newsgroup (which makes sense) but I don't know how they encode the
message ID. Each message has a unique ID. Depending on the features of
your newsreader, clicking on a link like this should open up your default
newsreader and go to that message if you have it on your machine. I use
Gravity 2.5 and it will only go to that message if I have it set to the
correct server. It won't automatically switch servers. Program like
Outlook Express which put all the different news servers you use in one
hierarchical list will usually go straight to the message regardless of
which server it is.

What happens if you don't have the message already downloaded? again,
that depends on your newsreader. Remember, OneNote can't make some
program do something it wasn't programmed to do. And you can't expect MS
to put a newsreader inside OneNote.

Have you been searching the web for info on how to do this? Or have you
just been waiting for us to do it for you. I found several discussions
about this in other forums just by searching. If I can find it in under a
minute then so can you.

Remember, the way you construct the links has nothing to do with OneNote.
OneNote just uses the standard methods that everyone else uses.
 
R

Rainald Taesler

Grant Robertson shared these words of wisdom:

Thanks for your suggestions, Grant.
I just would have needed a link for to one of my own threads tonight
when posting a reply to you ;-)
Of course the easiest way is to use google groups.

Yes, but that's not what I'm looking for.
... However, this
always requires you to be connected to the internet to see the
message.

Not only that.
Old fashioned in the style of working I simply do not like the
we-based fora/groups at all.
I need the stuff in a newsreader where I have it all together, can
jump up and down, mark postings and colour them, etc., etc.
I have seen hyperlinks to newsgroup messages in other newsgroup
messages. I think they start with "news://"

That's exactly what I'm looking for.

[...] Depending on the features of your newsreader, clicking on a
link like this should open up your default newsreader and go to
that message if you have it on your machine.

That's exactly what I am after.
I use Gravity 2.5

I tried it out and played with it (all the "pros" in my old main NG
used it). But after a while I returned to OE - mainly because of
wanting to have mail and news in the same place (that's one of the
main reason why I do use Outlook for mail only when sending "ink" mail
from my tablet said:
and it will only go to that message if I have it set to the
correct server. It won't automatically switch servers. Program
like Outlook Express which put all the different news servers
you use in one hierarchical list will usually go straight to the
message regardless of which server it is.

That's the way I know it. Interesting to hear that Gravitity in this
respect is less versatile than OE.
What happens if you don't have the message already downloaded?
again, that depends on your newsreader.

That's not a problem.
What I have in mind is to add links to stuff sitting in the OE
folders. The aim is to enable direct access to a posting / a thread
from a page where I have copied a posting or a part of it to OneNote.

And it would not be a problem - at least with OE - if its a posting
which had not been downloaded. OE opens a posting if one uses the
proper URL.
Remember, OneNote can't make some program do something
it wasn't programmed to do. And you can't expect MS
to put a newsreader inside OneNote.

Oh no! This was the last thing on mind ..
It's just about storing a link which opens a posting.
This works if the link has the format you were talking about.
Have you been searching the web for info on how to
do this? Or have you just been waiting for us to do
it for you.

Sorry Grant. We had something of this sort a few weeks ago (where it
was not me on whom you jumped with the allegation of wanting others to
do his job). Not again, pleeeease.

Just to make it clear: I did not at all ask for anybody else doing
something for me what I could do myself.
But "asked" a question (which makes a lot of a difference [hope you
are willing/able to understand this]). IMHO it's not only allowed but
one of the main purposes of a forum/NG to ask if someone else might
possibly know something.
Isn't that a far more economic way than working on inventing a wheel?
I simply thought that someone might know the notation of the URLs.
Nothing more.
I found several discussions about this in other forums just by
searching. If I can find it in under a minute then so can you.

No. I am not you. I am not that fast in googling my way around. And
honestly speaking even now I do not have any idea on what to search.

And just a pointer from you on your results would have been of help.
And it would have costs both of us less time ...
Remember, the way you construct the links has nothing to do with
OneNote. OneNote just uses the standard methods that everyone
else uses.

Exactly!!!
But I simply thought that something might know the syntax of the
".
That's all I had asked for. Not more, not less.

Rainald
 
G

Grant Robertson

Grant Robertson shared these words of wisdom:

Thanks for your suggestions, Grant.
I just would have needed a link for to one of my own threads tonight
when posting a reply to you ;-)

OK, since you begged for it... ;^)

Now, I don't ever use this and I don't use OE, but the messages I found
said to use "and the message ID which you get from the headers.
For instance, the message I am replying to has a message ID of

<[email protected]>

.... in my newsreader. You only use the part before the @ so I would
create a link by typing


possibly in angle brackets.

But I have tried several versions of this and none of it works in
Gravity. You might try some other variations for OE.

Search for "link to newsgroup message" but without the quotes on google.
The 5th hit gives you this:

http://www.google.com/url?sa=U&start=5
&q=http://www.velocityreviews.com/forums/t213053-how-do-i-include-a-link-
to-a-newsgroup-message.html&e=9797

which you may have to reconstruct.

I also found this:

http://www.insideoe.com/tips/makeOElinks.htm

but it doesn't talk about specific messages.

Maybe you could do this:

news://name-of-news-server/name-of-newsgroup/message-ID(before-the-@)

Personally, I think I would just print the newsgroup message to OneNote
or copy and paste the text or something. This whole thing is starting to
seem as if it will be very unreliable. The messages I have found claim
that one person's newsreader will use one message ID while someone elses
newsreader has a different message ID for the same message. This may be
due to the fact that the messages come to various people via different
routes. You will also have to depend on the messages to ALWAYS be
available in your newsreader and they might get purged out due to age or
something.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top