Hi Josh,
It sounds like you are in Advanced Settings for Field Options. Not sure that
we are on the same wavelength here. I hope that I understand your original
question, if not please try to provide more detail and post again.
What I meant was, in the pivot table displayed on the worksheet you can
select a field heading and drag it to a new place on the pivot table. You
will see the insertion point change to a shaded outline as you drag the
field heading around the worksheet.
Drag a field heading to the left side of the pivot table to set that field
as a row field. Now you should be able to see all the values for that field.
On the displayed pivot table, you can select a field item and drag it above
another field item to change the order of the displayed items. This new
ordering persists when you drag the field heading to the top of the pivot
table so that it becomes a page field.
There is no need to open any dialog boxes.
Ed Ferrero