Kyle,
Access doesn't work like that. If you delete *all* the records, and
then compact the database, the numbering will revert to start at 1
again. But deleting records will not allow those numbers to be re-used
(unless you insert them with an Append Query.
In general, the purpose of an Autonumber is to provide a unique
identifier for each record. As such, it shouldn't matter what the
number is. If you care what the number is, or if it's important to have
a numbering which is sequential, then you shouldn't be using an Autonumber.