That's a question that each user has to answer for him/her-self
The apps
are 'compatible' but by no means identical wrt their respective feature sets
& there are definitely pros & cons on each side. There always have been
differences but the gap widened considerably with the latest releases.
In all fairness, though, making the comparison using Office 2008 v. Office
2007 doesn't make the Mac version shine
The development of Office 2008
was hamstrung in a number of ways from the onset & resulted in a product
that is only 'good enough' in order to make the marketing deadline. [Just
one example: MacBU was instructed to drop VBA support because it was being
dropped altogether, even on the PC side. Once the Mac products were rebuilt
beyond the point of no return, guess what? The Win Office team incidentally
mentioned that they not only were keeping VBA in their products but actually
kicking it up a notch.] I'm confident that you'll be far more favorably
impressed when Office 2011 hits the streets late this year.
Regards |:>)
Bob Jones
[MVP] Office:Mac