Let's see now: Take 750 words a page, we're talking about documents of 5 to
9 pages? These are TINY!
Since it's a slow Sunday, just for grins I made a test document here. This
is in Word 2008, 12.2.4 on a Mac Pro with dual quads and 16 GB of RAM (which
is a generous hardware specification, suitable for producing major documents
for a living, as I do...)
Working in Page Layout View, I built a document in A4 with two columns, line
between, different headers odd and even, with dynamic headers and footers
(StyleRef fields in the headers and Page X of Y in the footers).
I added a Heading 1 on each page with List Numbering AND Field-numbering AND
a dynamic TIME field in it, and a Heading 2 containing the same. Then added
a Table of Contents.
This document is quite representative of a "Book" but is designed to be a
"worst case" obstacle course for Word. The results may surprise you (they
did me...)
At 1,500 pages, the document began to slow down. By 6,000 pages (over 2
million words) it was too slow to work with. By 12,288 pages, things were
unusably slow. Word hit a wall and maxed out: as I type this, Word is
sitting there with one core maxed out at 100% sucking 165 MB of real memory
and 265 MB of Virtual memory.
But it's still running. I can tell, because the CPU percentage and Memory
are changing slightly in Activity Monitor. Eventually, it will complete
that table of contents
Saving the document will be another test in
patience: it's taking several minutes per save.
Interestingly, Word's compression algorithm is VERY efficient. This
document is entirely text, and the total file size is 900 kb! In .doc
format, that would blow out to about 31 MB.
Word 2010 on the PC is a lot quicker for this kind of thing. It's
multi-threaded, so it is able to help itself to several CPU cores. It's
working on a copy of the same document, having helped itself to 276% CPU,
it's chugging away. It would be "just" useable with a document this size,
but sane users (i.e. Not me...) would split the document somewhere north of
3,000 pages.
It was interesting (to me...) to see that Mac Word 2008 can work with
documents north of 5,000 pages: I have never taken PC Word higher than that.
After 30 years of doing this, I still use the old techniques we have grown
up with (separate Chapter files and RD Fields) to avoid taking Word far
above 250 pages a document. But I have now learned that the limits of the
modern versions are much higher than that.
Some things, of course, never change. "You get what you pay for." There's
about 10 person-years worth of work in a "real" document of 5,000 pages.
Anyone who wants you to prepare a document of that size can thus afford to
pay for very serious workstations to create it on. Anyone who decides to
save a couple of thousand dollars by buying cheaper workstations will get
their document in 20 years of person-hours, rather than ten. As a
documentation contractor, I am all in favour of under-powered iMac
workstations and laptops: they create far more billable hours. When it's my
money on the line, I spend up on the hardware
Cheers all
Thanks for the helpful replies. I will work through them and report back.
Looking at tracking makes a lot of sense as I do a lot of changes in documents
of up to 7000 words. Also the slow scrolling is particularly noticeable in end
result two columned pages of around 4000 words (albeit after changes have been
accepted, although often in the same session).
--
The email below is my business email -- Please do not email me about forum
matters unless I ask you to; or unless you intend to pay!
John McGhie, Microsoft MVP (Word, Mac Word), Consultant Technical Writer,
McGhie Information Engineering Pty Ltd
Sydney, Australia. | Ph: +61 (0)4 1209 1410 | mailto:
[email protected]